Katie raised an interesting point in yesterday's comments box.
Well, interesting to me, though very probably mind-numbingly boring to the rest of you.
She said, 'I can't get over the British spelling of haemorrhoids though. Do you pronounce it haymer-hoids?'
Now, putting aside my unjustifiably piqued curiosity about (Heaven forfend!) any possible hæmorrhoidal fascination on Katie's part (OW! I felt that all the way from Berkeley), it has been a goodly long while since I last spuffled and blathered rantily about language and the abomination of Websterism, but it's a new year so let's start it as I mean to go on by offending people (well, Americans anyway, in revenge for Katie's translation of IBS as Irritable British Syndrome … hee hee) in my usual patronising and pedantic fashion.
Listen up: it's time to talk ligatures and diphthongs.
Quite apart from the fact that I have never been able to say the deliciously lippy and tongue-tastic word 'diphthong' without grinning, diphtongs (grin) and more specifically the lovely ligatures have long held a perverse and needlessly pedantic fascination for me.
If anyone's unsure, a diphthong is what happens when vowels cuddle up next to one another and a ligature occurs when things get out of hand and they fetch the bondage ropes and get a serious snuggle on.
Anyhoo … Ligatures:
For a start, I've always thought they look beautiful. Derived from Latin calligraphy the Æ and Œ ligatures are exceedingly sexy, especially when written in the late Roman uncial form.
But mostly it was the Cæsar/Kaiser thang that first grabbed my attention and made me aware of the ligature, way back in the mists of time when I was but a swotty little pimple-faced grammar school boy sitting in Latin class.
Such was the power of the ligature that it startled me into paying attention in class, wresting my adolescent mind - albeit temporarily - away from its musings on the strangely swelling bumps lately adorning the chest of the girl who lived down the road.
It was old Mr. Abbot, the fusty Latin Master who, during our very first Latin lesson invited guffaws of ridicule by declaring that Julius Cæsar should probably more correctly be pronounced Youlius Keezar.
Okay, so he backed it up with enough hard evidence to convince us that the Roman 'C' was a 'hard C' and that 'J' only came along much later and wasn't fully accepted until the 18th Century, but it still left poor Goldsmith, our token Jewish kid with several weeks of You-ish jokes to contend with.
Yet it was not the 'J' and the 'C' that lodged themselves in my brain and set me along the road to linguistic insanity, but the Æ ligature itself.
In defence of my pedantry please take into account that an upper-sixth former in the school I attended attained quite correctly the rank of 'Præfect' as opposed to 'Prefect' which was a type of Ford car.
I remember discussing the ligature thing with old Abbot a few years later - after I had discovered what ladybumps were and had endured five years of compulsory Latin - such were the diverse joys of English puberty in my day.
It seems that over a few hundred years, during the successive waves of Visigothic, Hunnish, Vandal, Ostrogothic, Teutonic, Lombard and Frankish invasions of the wretched corpse of the Roman Empire the ligature and the hard 'C' went their separate ways: the Hunnish and Teutonic languages of the Eastern half of Europe carried off the hard 'C' and the Frankish and Romance languages of Western Europe got custody of the ligature.
The result being the German 'Kaiser' (Roman hard 'C' and phonetically mispronounced digraph replacing the ligature) and the English 'Cæsar' (incorrect Romance soft 'C' and classically pronounced ligature) for the same word, neither of which Cæsar (Keezar) himself would have recognised unless he was very drunk.
Things stayed pretty much that way in the tiny and esoteric world of the ligature for over a thousand years (except in Scandinavia, where they have their own highly idiosyncratic set of rules for ligatures, along with everything else in life); English and German speakers knew where they stood, and as long as there were no Norwegians in the room everybody could pretty much guess what was being said.
Then - inevitably - some idiot sailed across the Atlantic, along came the US of A and it all ended in tears.
Millions of Europeans, with their wildly different pronunciations of the same letters, joined Russians, Africans and Asians in a race to empty the New World of its rightful peoples and replace them with what turned out to be a complete linguistic fuck-up unparalleled in history.
And into this mess rode my arch nemesis, Noah smegging Webster.
Yes, I'll admit that when you have a nation of several million illiterates from dozens of different countries and decide upon one official language it is a good idea to get them started speaking that language with some simplified spellings, especially with a language as rich and complex as English.
But for fuck's sake, as soon as they have a basic grasp of the language, teach it properly!
These days there is no excuse whatsoever (I don't count wilful ignorance as an excuse) for using Webster's simplified spellings.
'Pedophile'? What the fuck's that? Break the Webster version of the word down into its Classical roots and it means someone who likes feet!
Which is wrong to a quite hideous degree.
The word is 'pædophile.' Simplify it and the meaning is lost.
Use the ligature! Same goes for hæmorrhoids and diarrhœa, encyclopædia and œstrogen, æsthetics and œuvre.
Simplified spelling robs words of their meanings, reducing them to little more than random abstract symbols.
When it comes to ligatures, if you're too lazy to hit the 'alt' button on your Mac, at least use the ae and oe digraphs instead (as did the morons who made the signs for Boots the Chemist in yesterday's post). But never dispense with them altogether: 'encyclopedia' is ugly and horribly wrong, 'encyclopaedia' is inelegant and lazy, but 'encyclopædia' is sexy and cool.
And correct.
I know I keep harping on about Webster, but there are far more English speakers in the British Commonwealth and the world at large than there are in the USA and if we can spell correctly then people in the US can learn, too. Simplified spelling is for simpletons. Stop it. Now!
Websterism served its purpose 150 years ago but it is now as obsolete and worthless as the muzzle-loading flintlocks and wagon trains and smallpox-infected blankets that were its contemporaries.
I know it would cost money to change it after all this time and I know you really can't be bothered but mule-headedly sticking to a simplified and dumbed-down version of one of the world's richest and most eloquently expressive languages not only debases English but it makes Americans look lazy and dim. Sticking stubbornly with simplistic and inarticulate Websterism smacks of the thuggish, redneck, Joe Sixpack attitude that says intelligence is BAD (duh) and ignorance bliss, that showing culture and sophistication means you're unAmerican. It smacks frankly of dumb fucks with guns, scared shitless of being thought smart. Sorry, guys, but that's the view from the outside world.
If you can't give up your precious Webster at least make a start in the right direction and use the ligatures. Please. If you don't wish to adhere to historical precedence then use them because they are beautiful (æsthetically pleasing, if you will).
Do try to pronounce them correctly, too (a stressed and elongated 'ee'). If you're going to profess to speak and write in English, learning the language would be a good place to start.
Toodle Pip!
Your Pedantic Pal,
D.
33 comments:
Blæ, blæ, blæ. Whætever.
Hææ hææ hææ.
What the fæck? Wæ æin't Ænglish. Wæ is ræbæls.
Katie: lol!
Where the devil did all that come from?
Stay safe in the bad weather.......
Hee hee, Cali.
Those rebellious colonials, however, wrote and spoke perfect English, in the case of Jefferson and Franklin, beautifully so.
My beef is with those people who decided Webster's simplified version was not to be confined to those who needed it: to new immigrants and remedial readers.
Some people over there actually believe they're writing in English when they're using Websterisms. Sheesh!
Mum: School. And … er … learning to read as a toddler on my proof-reader mother's knee.
I've missed your little grouchy proper English lessons. :D
If I ever get a job with a keyboard I know I"m going to have to find that alt button for some reason, so why not look now.
å ´ Hmm..that doesn't look at all English. Maybe my keyboard is Spanish American only. But, I wanna be a Brit too!!! In spirit anyway.
Thank you for explaining the ligature and the diphthong. I'd never learned of the ligature and was remembering the diphthong to be the hangy down thing in the back of the throat! Yes, I've been breathing sawdust for about a week over here(kitchen revamp in progress) so I'm not the sharpest saw on the kitchen cabinet. ;)
What do I do after pressing alt Mr. professor?
Someœne woke up on the wrong side of the spider web! Pihæ!
I'm not saying that œ and æ ære nœt deliciously naughty, but they are gone with the dodo.
By the way, I personally blame you for the backwards, fucked up, non-metric measuring system of this country!
You should study Hungarian. It doesn't have diphthongs, but loves putting dots and hash marks over vowels. Hungarian has 14 vowels - made out of the standard 5. It also loves combining consonants: sz, zs, dz, dzs, ty, gy, ly. Many consonants make different sounds than you are used to; our 'c' is neither hard, nor soft. It's more like the sound 'ts' makes at the end of 'cats'. Soft C would be sz, and hard C is k. Top it all off, Hungarian has one of the most mind-boggling grammar in the world.
Hi, Shan!
The alt key is great fun.
Hit it together with ' for æ
with ; for …
with q for œ
with c for ç
with a for å
o for ø
0 for º
e for é
u for ü
n for ñ
and loads more, plus combinations like ê ô ï à á è ã etc.
and add the shift key for caps Æ Œ and so on.
Have fun!
Vanda: Ah, the ligature is alive and thriving in the world outside Webster's simplified 'American English'.
And I love feet and inches, ounces and pounds and all the rest; it teaches people maths.
I'd love to have a go at Hungarian, though I'm still having fun with Japanese at the moment and I would imagine learning both at the same time would be a recipe for madness.
I LOVE Katie's response here!
while they may be "æsthetically pleasing," language evolves. Evolve with it, Englishman!
Robyn: Outside of the US, the English language is a marvellous and constantly evolving beast. The main reason it can evolve is due its genetic make-up of Latin, Greek, French, German, Norse, Celtic, Indian, Arabic and many more languages.
What Webster did in the US was to make 'American English' a debased, simplified form of writing, and in doing so deprived it of its ability to evolve as anything other than a meaningless mælström of non-words such as 'normalcy' and encyclopedia (ugh).
As true English evolves outside the US, Webster's Simplified English will gradually atrophy and die, starved as it is of its rich linguistic heritage. It will become as dead as the Neanderthal while real English thrives all around it.
So nyah!
Hee hee hee.
I think I agree with you. I love the way Brits polish the English language. Did anyone speak better English than James Mason? Or Patrick Stewart? Brits rule! May the sun never set on the British Empire. Great post Dive. I enjoyed it.
You're definitely missing out on the finer things we've done to the English language here in the states.
Follow me fo'shizzle?
PS little sluggish on posting, with it being a new year I'm updating my blog ... becoming a sickness actually, the more I learn the more I want to tinker.
Marry mæ!
Oh. Wait.
My mother was an English teacher. She loved the language and taught me all this stuff. But it's no longer in our dictionaries (except the old ones). J and I have the OED on our wish list.
I don't have an alt key on my Mac. I have Control, Option and Apple. I'll try the Apple key with your marvelous suggestions and see what happens.
Mark: Ah, good old Patrick Stewart; from this month he becomes SIR Patrick Stewart as at long last he has been knighted for his services to sounding sexy.
Todd: I must confess that without the sterling efforts of such luminaries as Warren Gamaliel Harding and George Walker Bush English would be a somewhat less entertaining language.
Petrea: Hee hee.
Hoorah for English teachers!
Regrettably, thanks to Noah Webster, only the simplified form of the language appears in US dictionaries. The OED is great fun (if a little heavy to lug around with you); I insist on using it when playing Scrabble.
The alt key on the Mac is the old "Option" key.
For a quick guide to all the alternative characters available, dig around in your System Prefs under 'International' and open the 'Keyboard Viewer'. Launch it and then press the option key, the shift key, the Apple key or any combination of them.
Some of them (the accents) require you to hit the accent key first (for example: 'Option e for ´) and then to hit the letter key you want under the accent, to get é É á Á ü Ü ö Ö ê Ê î Î etc.
After a few tries you will find yourself automatically able to add accents while you type, together with tildes, çedillas, ligatures and all manner of other symbols.
Fun!
Though I must confess, there are days where it is like sitting in a room of long finger nails on the chalkboard.
e.g. "a'ight, I'll be headin' out in'a short bit." - said by a professional news anchor (sigh).
Congrats to Sir Patrick Stewart. A true gentleman and one of the finest actors of the stage and screen the world has ever known.
There is lots of love over here for Jean Luc Pica...er.. I mean Sir Patrick Stewart!
Found it. Delight! Bliss! Merci!
I've been limping along with a system I created. I copied accents, cedilles, etc. from the web and saved them to a document. Then when I needed them I'd fetch them. It slows one's typing. This is much better. I'm in pedant heaven.
Todd and Mark: Yes, I am so glad I got to see him in Waiting For Godot last year. He is awesome up close.
Petrea: Woohoo! I am so happy to have been able to help. Believe me, once you get used to using the system it becomes as quick as normal typing.
Enjoy!
Thank you for explaining all the doodads on my Mac. Now, I can happily say that one of my favorite names is Renæ.
Your word verification is hatie.
I used to own a hatie but it is a gas guzzler.
Well I couldn't read all that I'm afraid, but I see nothing strange at all in the spelling. Well, why would I? ;)
How do Americans spell it then? I'm intrigued...
...and how did this come up? er...
So Dive,
I am curious.
In what dictionary can you find the origin of "Fuck? Is the original "Fuak", "Fook", Feek", Is it a verb or a noun? Similes?
Please give us the proper English origin!
I want to give you the proper English salutation!
While researching I see that two of my favorite English actors were born in Yorkshire. Sir Patrick Stewart in Mirfield, West Yorkshire and James Mason in West Riding of Yorkshire. Are these places in close proximity? Or would it compare to both being born in California? Can you shed some light on this Dive? Thanks.
Gee, and all this time I thought a diphthong was a tæny wæny bikini for bæthing in the oceæn.
Loved your rant and all the comments!
MAria: Now you'll have me singing "Walk Away, Renée' all morning.
Which is actually no bad thing.
Lynn: You must have the only computer left in the world that cannot read ligatures and accents. I know from many previous attempts that I'll not persuade you to buy a new one but I am sure the Science Museum would give you a good price for it.
This all sprang from a comment Katie made about the previous post.
And of course my monstrous pedantry.
Neetzy: 'Fuck' has been around since at least the middle ages and is probably Germanic (Saxon) in origin, in which case we'll have been using it in England since my own Saxon ancestors came here in around 450AD.
The Old German antecendent was probably 'focka' (to push, strike or copulate).
Like the 'C' word (see my old posts on the subject) it was not originally offensive.
The earliest written use of it in the OED (in its current perjorative sense) is from 1503, though of course it would have been in spoken use a lot longer.
Some morons think it is acronymic, but they're the type who would consult Wikipedia before the OED.
So now you can salute me correctly. Hee hee.
Mark: Yorkshire is our largest county and our lads were born wuite a distance apart.
Neither of them has any trace of a Yorkshire accent as they attended RADA and adopted a southern English accent. For an actor back then, to have a regional accent was to be out of work so they had to learn what was called 'BBC English' to earn a living.
Lupine Lady: Hee hee. Katie certainly started something with her comment!
Hee hee, Todd.
Truly fucking comprehensive.
Oh yea ... if you haven't paid a visit to the Urban Dictionary I encourage you to do so. It's fucking tremendous!
Hee hee. I'll check it out, Todd.
Not only did I garner a true education in reading the post... but a greater one in reading your mini-insights in all these comments.
Though I must confess feeling slightly miffed that not only does American English suffer the loss of the ligatures, and the proper intelligent use of the word "fuck" (instead of just stringing it along with mother repetatively), but we have nothing even remotely touching on the gems of "swotty" or "toodle pip".
:)
This is your best post ever. Love it! Love the lessons on the Mac too ... I'm off to try some `å (well, it might take a little mastering). You can see by the response that your friends truly appreciate it when you give them, us, a literary lesson! xxxxx
Hi, A.A!
I wonder if you're the same 'A' who used to blog three years ago.
I do hope so, but even if you're not, welcome anyway.
Mme: Hee hee. You are too kind, as ever.
I'm so glad to have been able to point out the Mac shortcuts to people. They make typing so much easier.
Hahahaha!
Thanks for that one, Todd. The phrase for ugs over here is 'face like a bag of spanners'.
Post a Comment